Senate offers first look at its state budget proposal
A budget proposal unanimously passed out of the Senate Finance Committee this past Tuesday would continue, in general, investments in public education funding made in the 2019 school-finance law, HB 3.
The budget could reach the floor for full Senate approval Tuesday, and then legislators will try to reconcile it with an eventual House budget proposal. The first full look at a more detailed Senate budget is overshadowed by decisions on how $17.9 billion in federal stimulus funding for Texas public education will be used. (See “Stop the Swap.”)
Bill that would pave the way for state takeovers of school districts faces harsh critique
Rep. Alma Allen (D-Houston), a former Houston ISD administrator who serves on the House Public Education Committee, had a pointed line of questioning this past Tuesday on the committee’s hearing of a bill that would remove legal roadblocks for a state takeover of Houston ISD. “This bill simply gives the state the right to take over education in the state of Texas,” Allen said. “I don’t think that’s the solution.”
Last year, Education Commissioner Mike Morath announced he would remove the elected Houston ISD school board and replace it with a Texas Education Agency board of managers. He claimed authority for the move because the district did not meet state accountability ratings for one school out of some 280 campuses—and even that campus’ rating was in dispute. Houston ISD filed a lawsuit to stop the takeover and won an injunction stopping the action on the grounds that Morath had not followed the law and exceeded his authority. Two state attempts to overturn the injunction failed, and the lawsuit continues.
HB 3270 would change state law to give the education commissioner the authority and procedural steps needed to bypass a legal challenge like Houston ISD’s. It would grant enormous power to the commissioner, thus creating a danger of statewide takeovers of democratically elected school boards for school accountability ratings and for questions over local school district operations. “This bill would make Education Commissioner Mike Morath investigator, judge, and jury, not subject to outside review,” said Zeph Capo, Texas AFT president.
Allen said we need to concentrate on giving schools the resources they need and also respect the teaching profession with higher pay. “We need to elevate the teaching profession,” she said. “Treat teachers as if they are professionals. And the state of Texas does not do that. That is my proposal.” The bill was left pending in committee, and Texas AFT will continue to oppose this assault on democratically elected school boards.
Already bad rating system would get drastically worse with D-and-F bill
Texas AFT has long opposed the A-F school rating system, and the punitive sanctions that come with it; we view the system as an unfair and ineffective way to look at the actual performance of a campus and district. Nevertheless, HB 3731 would make it worse
redefining an “unacceptable rating” to include D-rated schools, as opposed to just F-rated under current law. Texas AFT opposes this bill because it would give a political appointee (the commissioner of education), who also defines these labels, even more power to take over democratically-elected school boards. Although Dutton made minor changes to the bill that would not penalize campuses after receiving the first D, the bill would still significantly increase the number of school districts that would be vulnerable to state takeover in the future.
Local union president pushes for anti workplace-bullying bill
Northside AFT President Wanda Longoria testified this past Tuesday in favor of a bill—HB 256 (Philip Cortez, D-San Antonio)— that would require districts to include a policy for “anti-bullying measures to address bullying in the workplace, including provisions to address the bullying of a teacher by a parent.”
Longoria, who as a teacher faced bullying and legal threats from parents, told House Public Education Committee members that she suffered significant stress and health issues from the incident, which had a noticeable impact on her teaching.
“I know what being the best teacher I can be for students means,” she said. “It means a teacher is happy, focused, free of fear or intimidation, confident in the delivery of instruction, knowing there will be support there should it be needed. Teachers show up and support their students every day providing a safe learning environment. They need to know there are laws that will secure a safe teaching environment.”
Texas AFT has been successful at getting local school boards to pass anti-workplace-bullying policies, but this bill would require a statewide adoption, thus ensuring every district had a policy in place. HB 256 was left pending in committee.
Messy virtual education proposals need further study in proposed commission
This past Tuesday, the House Public Education Commission heard HB 1468 (Keith Bell, R-Forney) which addresses numerous provisions of law on the funding and operation of virtual instruction. Texas AFT has concerns about this bill because it provides too many opportunities for the expansion of shoddy virtual schools and does not ensure protections for teachers doing virtual instruction. The bill was left pending, with possible changes forthcoming.
Texas AFT supports HB 3643 (Ken King, R-Canadian), which would create the Texas Commission on Virtual Education. The commission would develop recommendations on the funding and delivery of virtual education. While the pandemic has shown the need to address virtual education issues, a commission would be better suited to evaluating what is effective, rather than legislating changes in the current session. The bill, which we support, was left pending.
Legislative Briefs from the week of March 29:
- We previously reported on SB 28, which would take powers to regulate charter schools away from locally elected officials and the State Board of Education. The bill passed the Senate Education Committee on Wednesday on a 6-3 vote, with our friends Senators José Menéndez, Beverly Powell, and Royce West voting to keep elected oversight. Although there was a committee substitute, the bill still strips authority from elected SBOE members to veto new charter applicants and adds a new “supermajority” vote requirement of the SBOE that will effectively disenfranchise minority SBOE members.
- HB 1525 (Dan Huberty, R-Humble) passed the House Public Education Committee. It’s a “clean-up” bill for HB 3, the school finance bill from last session. The bill adjusts weights and allotments for funding, modifies tax-rate laws, and adjusts numerous other components of school finance. One harmful change would make non-certified teachers eligible for the Teacher Incentive Allotment (TIA) programs. Although TIA has been touted as a way to pay the supposedly “best” teachers more money, the program has significant flaws and should not be seen as any kind of solution to the state’s history of underpaying educators. (TIA identifies the “best” teachers, in large part, by the results of their students’ STAAR test scores.) We have concerns about any expansion of TIA until teachers statewide receive fair pay and districts no longer rely on faulty assessments for added compensation.
- Texas AFT supports HB 1068 (Alma Allen, D-Houston), a bill heard by the House Public Education Committee, which allows school district employees, including bus drivers and office workers, to use available personal leave for compensation on school holidays for which they are not paid.
- Conservative lawmakers perpetuating the myth of voter fraud advanced bills to suppress voting Thursday. The Senate passed SB 7 (Bryan Hughes, R-Mineola), which would limit the extension of early voting hours, criminalize distribution of absentee ballots in some situations, and outlaw drive-thru voting. The House Elections Committee heard a similar bill, HB 6 (Briscoe Cain, R-Deer Park), which also would make disabled voters prove their disability before receiving a mail-in ballot and place limits on voting locations. Cain’s procedural mistake the previous week forced him to cancel the hearing on the bill, after more than a hundred witnesses were ready to testify.
- The full House will consider HB 699 by Jon Rosenthal (D-Cy Fair) on Tuesday. The bill—named “Riley’s Rule” after the student who inspired it—would require school districts to excuse absences and grant promotion to students with serious or life-threatening illnesses.
Next Week In the House
The House Public Education Committee will be busy next Tuesday hearing dozens of bills on topics that Texas AFT has been monitoring closely, including these Texas AFT-supported bills:
- HB 41 (James Talarico, D-Round Rock) sets class size limits and student/teacher ratios for prekindergarten classes provided by or on behalf of public schools.
- HB 81 (Eddie Rodriguez, D-Austin) lays out the process for public school campus’s election under a campus turnaround plan to operate as a community school, and creates statewide standards for the model .
- HB 97 (Gina Hinojosa, D-Austin) would restrict the use of a student’s discipline history in the admission policy of an open-enrollment charter school.
- HB 450 (Mary Gonzalez, D-El Paso) would require at least 18-month’s notice to establish a new open-enrollment charter school or campus.
- HB 1249 (Anna-Maria Ramos, D-Dallas) would require public accessibility of the most recent open-enrollment charter school annual financial statements.
The House Pensions, Investments & Financial Services Committee will meet on Wednesday to hear several bills related to Teacher Retirement System of Texas pensions, including cost-of-living increases for retirees.
Next Week In the Senate
The Senate Education Committee will be hearing bills Thursday, including these Texas AFT-supported bills:
- SB 462 (Lucio, D-Brownsville) Would allow school transportation funds to be used for the transporting of meals and instructional materials to a student’s residence.
- SB 1267 (West, D-Dallas) is the result of a series of meetings and discussions among education-related stakeholder groups, including Texas AFT, to try to reduce the amount of professional development requirements teachers have and include more relevant choices for educators.
Voted out of the House Public Education Committee on Tuesday, March 30
Texas AFT supported:
HB 363 (Gary Van Deaver, R-New Boston) would require a third party to protect student-identifying information by utilizing a unique Texas Student Data System ID and following state-required data sharing agreements.
HB 2120 would require districts to create a process—unless otherwise provided by existing law or policy—for school employees, parents and students to receive administrative hearings and an appeals process for complaints filed with the district. It also requires districts to provide a resolution of a complaint no later than 120 calendar days after the filing of the complaint.
HB 2519 (Drew Darby, R-San Angelo) seeks to address teachers losing their certification for not meeting deadlines for resigning from a district. Under the bill, the State Board for Educator Certification could not revoke a certificate for contract abandonment if the educator “has no disciplinary history with the board; and demonstrates that the notice of resignation given was reasonable under the circumstances.” It also requires a board, during a disciplinary proceeding to suspend or revoke a certificate or permit, to include in the findings any available information regarding the respondent’s response to the allegations on which the proceeding is based.
The bill also would ensure rural districts are represented on SBEC and revises the notice to teachers regarding suspension or revocation of certificate or permit to require clear, unambiguous language as well as prompt delivery.
HB 353 (Harold Dutton, D-Houston) would include disaggregated data on student performance by sex for all ethnic groups in calculation of accountability ratings.
HB 129 (Mary Gonzalez, D-El Paso) as substituted, adds cyberbullying prevention and response, digital ethics, etiquette safety and security, and media literacy to topics covered under curriculum standards for digital citizenship.
HB 2287 (Senfronia Thompson, D-Houston) authorizes TEA to collect and share additional data for the Collaborative Task Force on Public School Mental Health Services related to the impact of mental health programs on academic achievement, school discipline, and students’ well-being.
HB 2954 (Thompson) creates a suicide prevention, intervention, and postvention program for optional implementation at an elementary campus of a school district that has experienced a suicide among its students or has reasonable concern regarding the risk of suicide among its students.
Texas AFT opposed:
HB 2557 (Glenn Rogers, R-Graford) allows a district or charter board of trustees to approve a program allowing retired law enforcement officers or honorably retired military veterans to serve as volunteer security personnel at a school and carry a handgun in fulfillment of that role. Texas AFT opposes this bill.
Left pending after hearings in the House Public Education Committee on Tuesday, March 30
Texas AFT supported:
HB 2344 (Erin Zwiener, D-Dripping Springs) allows the non-multiple choice portion of a state reading assessment instrument or an English I or English II end-of-course assessment to be used as part of a classroom portfolio method to assess writing performance.
HB 3346 (Terry Meza, D-Irving) creates a state accountability indicator of achievement for improving student preparedness for success in subsequent grade levels—other than assessment instruments like STAAR—for public elementary, middle school, and junior high campuses.
Voted out of the Senate Education Committee on Wednesday, March 31:
Texas AFT supported:
SB 89 (José Menéndez, D-San Antonio) requires a written supplement to a student’s IEP indicating whether a full evaluation was completed in the 2019-2020 school year or the 2020-2021 school year, and whether or not the services available to the student were interrupted, reduced, delayed, suspended, or discontinued. The bill is intended to help inform student’s subsequent teachers and it expires in 2023.